Considering the territory, culture and age range for which the programme is intended:
TARGET AUDIENCE
- Is it appropriate and attractive?
- Is it successfully entertaining?
- Does it inform?
- Does it respect the target audience/ take them seriously?
- Does it empower the target audience?
IDEA
- Is it interesting?
- Is it original?
- Does it have a new approach? Is it fresh?
- Does it motivate the viewer?
- Does it achieve its objective/ purpose?
SCRIPT
- Is the structure/ balance good?
- Is the subject well research and developed?
- Is the dialogue of high quality?
- Are the characters well developed? Are their actions motivated?
REALIZATION
- Is the idea well translated to television? (Visual style, camera work, style, editing, music of performance, etc.)
- Is the pace/ rhythm of the programme successful?
- Is television the best medium for this idea?
P/S: Thanks for sharing, Ms. Siew Wai!